Which keeps you up at night: Alternative currencies or alternative payment technology?

Nobody gets me Bitcoins!

Image by zcopley via Flickr

There was an interesting article and discussion today on American Banker‘s BankThink. American Banker’s Jeremy Quittner wrote an article about Bitcoin being highlighted in a legal case on an episode of the Good Wife this week. Brief Clip

If you want to learn more about Bitcoin, here’s another great Quittner article from a few week’s back For Banks, Digital Currency Poses Threat — and Opportunity

Read the Good Wide Bitcoin article here: ‘Cool, But a Hassle’: Bitcoin Tests Merchants’ Patience

I added comments on American Banker, and wondered what you thought of Bitcoin? What are you most focused on in fintech? Alternative currencies like Bitcoin/Facebook Credits/iTunes or mobile money movement through more traditional channels with less-traditional technologies (think Dwolla, Square, Paypal, etc). Am I missing something on alt-currencies? Let me know via Twitter: @leimer

Here were my comments on the American Banker post:

Are alternative payments like Bitcoin a curiosity or just a progression toward the ongoing transactional shift away from traditional banking (or traditional currencies for that matter)? Though the volume of alt-payments/mobile payments is growing rapidly (astronomically some might say), the vast majority of consumers and merchants still do not see the use of the established volume leader, Paypal (amazing growth under the recently departed Scott Thompson), as a form of regular payment activity.

The innovations of currency alternatives like Bitcoin (and mobile payments) are a great destination, a great promise of better technology and control around money movement and control for consumers and businesses, but it is often an overhyped ‘promise’ of what is to come…Yes, volumes are on the rise. Yes, some amazing technology is being developed and implemented. Yes, the user experiences around contactless payment (NFC, alternative POS), and alt-currencies (Facebook credits, even iTunes) are currently being established (certainly Google and Apple will have some say about this).

But how much do banks need to pay attention to alternative currencies? Yes, we should be prepared to integrate and embrace technology change around money movement of any kind. But, if you’re in banking or fintech, you’re probably more closely watching alt/mobile payment volumes rise and crafting/enhancing your payment/money movement technology at your own financial institutions in response. I wouldn’t worry as much about the Bitcoin model/alt currencies just yet. They’ll most likely take the back seat to money movement through traditional players (and in the alt-currency space, I would be more concerned about Facebook Credits than Bitcoin).

Money movement alternatives like Paypal, ZashPay, Cashedge/Fiserv’s PopMoney, Dwolla, Square (+ others) do have a built in ‘hassle’ within the user experience because of the need to link to additional traditional banking accounts somewhere. The person/merchant receiving funds also have to be on the same network or sign up/trust these providers. It seems like the only way to eliminate this is with an established alt-currency (how is the Euro working out, let alone the anti-banking alternative digital Bitcoins?), or an established open-API method of money movement (better solution). To address the overall UX, we need to integrate both technologies into the devices we carry everyday (our phones), whether it be through form factor (NFC/alt-device) or network apps (Paypal POS, Proxense, etc.). The UX still would take a back seat for alt-currencies like Bitcoin until you bridge the additional gap in the trust factor (Paypal itself, even with great UX, still isn’t as trusted for money transfers as a traditional financial institution).

We will have some time to watch these standards develop. As we watch the volume of alt-payments rise, the overall volume will be a limited space in the overall consumer/b2b payment pie. The true revolution in banking that everyone sees coming like a lumbering freight train is still there. It’s less about alt-currencies and more about overall experience through technology. But Movenbank and Simple aren’t going to change the world of banking overnight, nor has (or will) Bitcoin or Paypal for that matter. But changes are here, they’re real, and there are more are on the way (Paypal, Square, and Dwolla are will see monster jumps this year to be sure).

The fact that the Good Wife even tackled the subject is interesting. The audience for the episode probably increased awareness of Bitcoin in Peoria more than anything Bitcoin’s banking industry coverage ever did.

Stop Blocking, Start Embracing the Social Enterprise

The recent Dreamforce conference in San Francisco focused on the rise of the ‘social enterprise.’

We can loosely define the social enterprise as the democratization of business processes through technology channels that remove barriers for engaging communication by flattening organizational levels, enhance the sharing of innovation and ideas and increase opportunities for enriched connections among employees, customers and inter-related groups.

By leveraging the social model, the banking industry has the potential for a dynamic period of innovation, and an even chance of remaining relevant to our customers — and employees — as they gain control of the conversation.

During the conference keynote, Salesforce.com’s CEO, Marc Benioff drew a comparison between the social powered revolutions we saw during the Arab Spring and the evolution within the business world. Though Salesforce is recognized for innovation in cloud computing and customer relationship management, the company’s deliberate pivot to embrace social technologies as integral to their business model is significant for the banking industry, which has historically been less than accommodating toward new technologies.

Read the full post on American Banker’s BankThink.

If you cannot access the link, or if it requires a subscription, please email me at bleimer@me.com and I will send you the story directly.

What do you think?

You can follow me on Twitter, connect on LinkedIn, and add me to your circles on Google+.

Additional Media featuring @leimer
Friends With Benefits (Bank Technology News)
Bankers, Pay Attention to Google+ (American Banker Bank Think)
Smart Phones Alter Banking Landscape (ABA Banking Journal)
Dickens' Spirits Speak on Tech Spending (American Banker Bank Think)
A 'Hunch' That Could Yield Useful Marketing Lessons (American Banker Bank Think) 
How to Get Started in Social Media (American Banker)
5 Social Media Best Practices (Information Week Financial Services)
Social Media Best Practices (Adobe Experience Delivers)
"The Deer Have Guns" (American Banker)
Citi, USAA Execs Share Social Media Best Practices (Bank Systems & Technology)
Reviewed: Bank 2.0
Celent Banking Innovation and Insight Day Recap 
Celent Event Photos 
Celent Innovation & Insight Day - Social Media Panel 

Summary of Engagement Banking Meet-Up in San Francisco

Last Friday evening, I was fortunate to spend some time at an impromptu Bank 2.0 MeetUp in San Francisco with author and engagement banking pioneer Brett King.  Joining us in the conversation about the next generation of banking was Michael Degnan, Engagement Banking Leader for Sapient Nitro’s Financial Services Center of Excellence, as well as Scott Sanborn, the CMO of SF-based Lending Club, which had just closed a $25 million round of new funding earlier in the week.

While I won’t be providing a complete tick tock of our MeetUp in this post, it was great to talk about the future of banking and the shift in technology and customer expectations with some of the more innovative thinkers in the space.  It was also nice to meet and talk shop in person after conversing through Twitter. While I am huge proponent of social collaboration and conversation, nothing beats the impromptu dialogue of a conference break out session or panel, and all those side conversations that inevitably occur.  I applaud Brett’s efforts to set up MeetUp’s during his business trips, and encourage others to embrace social connections and follow suit.

I really enjoyed talking to Michael Degnan and learning more about Sapient Nitro’s involvement in engagement banking, as well as talking social data.  How can a user’s social graph be leveraged to offer enhancements to the customer experience and transaction components for traditional banking channels? What about ways to improve the investing and portfolio management customer experience?  We talked about the latter after Brett announced S&P’s credit downgrade of the U.S. government to the group. Talk about a conversation thud – “the most risk-free investment now has risk”.  Boom. Now it was some time for some navel gazing and a moment to ponder Monday’s market open and how our portfolios melt away.

Outside of that news-bomb, it was great to get an update on Lending Club, and hear about their recent funding successes.  As companies and personal investors look for better returns and diversification (especially in light of recent events), the social lending space will continue to grow (Lending Club added $20M in new loans in June alone).  More power to them if the larger banks aren’t as willing to lend and embrace the social aspect of what has been estimated to be at $60B P2P market through family and friend loans.  Propser, the other big-player in the space along with Zopa, has received huge rounds of investment of late, including $150M in June, and another $17M from Google’s Eric Schmidt.

Brett’s project list is intriguing as well, including a follow up to his successful book, Bank 2.0, which has been an industry board room topic since it launched last year.  I was especially interested in learning more about his mobile-optimized banking startup MovenBank, which has promise to be an important player in the banking landscape.  Brett talked about how MovenBank is being designed to remove the friction caused by existing technology and locational constraint that exists between financial institutions and their customers today.  I imagine that Brett’s literal napkin diagram of the existing banking structural constraints has been repeated across the jet-setting pace of his past year’s conference schedule. I remarked about my feeling of deja vu after seeing Al Gore deliver his “Inconvenient Truth” presentation with my wife in San Francisco two years before the book and movie came out (though Gavin Newsom and Jerry Brown weren’t seated at the table as they were when we saw Gore) .  It makes sense that the author of Bank 2.0 would be designing customer-experience-driven processes to avoid the tension created by existing banking structures, and that is exactly why it’s engaging.  There’ll be many of us in the industry secretly rooting for MovenBank.

Whether MovenBank intrigues the larger banking community as much as BankSimple has (or had, at least by the dearth of recent coverage) remains to be seen.  I can only hope that Brett’s partners will continue to do something the banking industry sorely needs, and that is to further shake things up to the benefit of the banking customer and for the overall user-experience (which has huge gaps, as you occasionally see in my tweets about online banking, PFM, mobile, and UX).  The other purpose of MovenBank, in my opinion, is to inspire further innovation.  Companies waving the flag of true innovation are rare in the financial services industry, whether this is due to natural barriers of entry or the conservative nature of bank technologists and their C-level counter-suits. Disruption isn’t just coming, it’s already here (e.g. mobile payment).

We need to create more Bank 2.0 converts and more “engaged bankers” in our industry (maybe by the time Bank “3.0″ or whatever Brett calls it comes out, more of the industry will have read his first book).  As a reluctant “banker” (I don’t think anyone in banking technology, analytics/data or financial marketing ever really calls themselves a ‘banker’),  one has to encourage this type of industry-shaking thinking and technology development however we can (as I covered in a year-end post on American Banker’s BankThink).  If not to benefit the customers and industry we serve, but to improve our own user experience as consumers and business owners as well.

What do you think?

You can follow me on Twitter, connect on LinkedIn, and add me to your circles on Google+.

Additional Media featuring @leimer
Friends With Benefits (Bank Technology News)
Bankers, Pay Attention to Google+ (American Banker Bank Think)
Smart Phones Alter Banking Landscape (ABA Banking Journal)
Dickens' Spirits Speak on Tech Spending (American Banker Bank Think)
A 'Hunch' That Could Yield Useful Marketing Lessons (American Banker Bank Think) 
How to Get Started in Social Media (American Banker)
5 Social Media Best Practices (Information Week Financial Services)
Social Media Best Practices (Adobe Experience Delivers)
"The Deer Have Guns" (American Banker)
Citi, USAA Execs Share Social Media Best Practices (Bank Systems & Technology)
Reviewed: Bank 2.0
Celent Banking Innovation and Insight Day Recap 
Celent Event Photos 
Celent Innovation & Insight Day - Social Media Panel 

My Latest Post on American Banker’s BankThink: Bankers, Pay Attention to Google+

Google just launched a social sharing platform called Google+.

And it doesn’t suck

And over 10 million people are already using it.

What does it mean for your bank and how it should view Google+ and the social media landscape?

View the full post on American Banker’s BankThink.  Link: http://t.co/6bmOmdG

Google Plus Functions

 

Bradley Leimer manages the online service group for Mechanics Bank in Richmond, Calif. The views expressed here are his own. You can follow him on Twitter and find him on LinkedIn. And now Google+.

If you can’t view the full post, please email me directly at: bleimer@me.com or bradley_leimer@mechanicsbank.com

I have a ‘hunch’ this is an important marketing lesson (my recent post on American Banker’s Bank Think)

Which way do you prefer your roll of toilet paper to hang? Should the paper roll out from the front of the roll, or should it roll from the back? You might wonder what that has to do with banking, but I bet you thought a few seconds about your preference. That’s the genius behind a New York start-up called Hunch, which bills itself as a way to personalize the Internet by making smart recommendations about what you might like based on a series of questions.

Read the full post at American Banker’s Bank Think

Bradley Leimer is a dedicated senior marketer with experience in brand development, online / offline marketing, database marketing, web development, and online banking / mobile financial applications. You can follow him on Twitter and find him on LinkedIn.